Robin Hood Spotlight

A Gest of Robyn Hode

Spotlight Review by Allen W. Wright
(December 1997, revised continually)

Introduction

Under a variety of titles -- A Gest, Merry Geste or Lytell Geste --, A Gest of Robyn Hode was printed and reprinted numerous times in the 16th century. The earliest surviving edition dates from around AD 1500, and therefore the Gest is one of the earliest surviving Robin Hood stories.

Current scholarship suggests it was originally composed in the latter half of the 1400s.  Also, some historians feel it was compiled from previous, but now lost, ballads. Others have argued that later ballads were cut down from the tales in the Gest.

Clocking in at around 13,900 words, it's not only the longest early Robin Hood story, but the longest English outlaw story of its day. So, Robin Hood writers and scholars are bound to be drawn to it.

Gest, by the way, could mean story, tale, adventure or in this case, deed.

This ballad would not have been sung as later ballads were, but instead would have been spoken. American musician Robert Frank recorded a translated version of the ballad, which he speaks while playing music. Oxford scholar Douglas Gray commented that this is almost certainly how the original tale would have been performed.

Summary of the Gest

The Gest is divided into eight sections, known as Fyttes. Here's a breakdown of the main action for you.

Fytte 1 -- Robin wants to have a guest before they eat. Little John finds a poor knight in threadbare clothing. The knight's son killed someone in a joust and the knight had to borrow 400 pounds from St. Mary's Abbey, York to pay the bail. Now, the loan is due, and the knight doesn't have the money and will lose his lands. Finding him to be honest, Robin loans him the money and gives him fine clothing. He sends Little John along with the knight. 

Fytte 2 -- The abbot of St. Mary's and others are eager to seize the knight's land. The knight shows up and pretends to be broke. They show no mercy. And therefore, when the knight pays up he doesn't give them a tip. The knight returns home, collects the money, and makes a gift of fine bows and arrows, to repay Robin. On his way to Barnsdale (Robin's base), he is delayed to help a yeoman in a wrestling match. 

Fytte 3 -- Meanwhile, Little John goes to Nottingham and enters an archery contest. The sheriff is impressed and drafts Little John into his service. After spending some months with the sheriff, Little John causes trouble, fights and recruits the sheriff's cook and they make off with the sheriff's treasure. Later, they lure the sheriff into meeting Robin Hood. In exchange for his freedom, the sheriff promises not to harm Robin. 

Fytte 4 -- Waiting for the knight to return his loan, Robin and his men intercept the high cellarer of St. Mary's abbey. The monk is rude and dishonest, and so Robin robs him of 800 pounds, claiming the virgin Mary has sent this payment. When the knight does show up, Robin gives him another 400 pounds. 

Fytte 5 -- The Sheriff of Nottingham holds an archery contest for a gold and silver arrow. Robin wins the contest. But his men are ambushed, Little John is wounded, and they take refuge at the castle of the knight (now called Sir Richard at the Lee). 

Fytte 6 -- The sheriff goes to the king for help, and returns to capture Sir Richard. Sir Richard's wife goes to Robin for help. Robin rescues the knight, kills the sheriff and flees to the forest. 

Fytte 7 -- Planning to deal with Robin personally, the king goes to the forest disguised as an abbot. He makes friends with Robin. They have an archery contest which Robin loses. The knight discovers the king's true identity. Robin enters the king's service. 

Fytte 8 -- The king and his men disguise themselves as outlaws and go to Nottingham. Robin serves the king for 15 months. Broke and bored, he returns to Barnsdale, reforms the band, and they stay as outlaws for 22 years. Robin is bled by his cruel cousin, the Prioress of Kirklees, and dies. The Gest also implicates the prioress's lover Sir Roger of Doncaster (Donkestere or Donkesly) in Robin's death.

The Archery Contest in The Adventures of Robin Hood (1938)

Robin kneeling before the king in The Adventures of Robin Hood (1938)

Later adaptations of the Gest

Some of this summary is probably familiar to you. Later ballads are based on the Gest. Many of these incidents appear in children's books, like Howard Pyle's classic The Merry Adventures of Robin Hood of Great Renown in Nottinghamshire. The knight's debt is a major part of Robin McKinley's feminist novel The Outlaws of Sherwood.

The archery contest is a staple of nearly every Robin Hood movie and TV show, as is the pardon from the king (Edward in the ballad, usually Richard I in the films and novels). Robin and Marian has an unusual take on Robin's death.

The 1980s television series Robin of Sherwood starring Michael Praed and Jason Connery borrowed from the Gest in several episodes. The archery contest is in "Robin Hood and the Sorcerer", Robin enters and later leaves the king's service in "The King's Fool", and Sir Richard is in debt to the abbot of St. Mary's in "Herne's Son." The Abbot of St. Mary's aspect of the Gest also appear in the 1975 TV series The Legend of Robin Hood. The abbot and Sir Roger of Doncaster also appear in the 1969/1973 movie Wolfshead.

And the earlier 1950s TV series, Richard Greene's The Adventures of Robin Hood also borrowed heavily from the Gest. Sir Richard's debt to the Prior of Emmet (as in Pyle's book) is covered in the episode "The Knight Who Came to Dinner". An archery contest and the siege of Richard's castle occur in "The Challenge".

The Gest and History

Historians, such as John Bellamy, continue to focus on the Gest in their attempts to find an original Robin Hood. The description of Robin's Yorkshire haunts is unusually specific. (Sherwood Forest is never mentioned in the Gest.)

There is much debate about when the story is set. or even when it was composed. Some feel it occurs in the 13th century. Others prefer the 14th century. Dates of composition range from before 1400 to the 1460s.

Scholars also disagree which Edward the king is meant to be. In the early 19th century, Joseph Hunter found the king's journey in the Gest is similar to that of Edward II's. There was even a Robyn Hood serving as a porter in this king's court. However, other details point to the reign of Edward III. Professor Stephen Knight stated in his 1994 study of Robin Hood that the king may have been Edward IV, who was likely the king at the time of composition.

But Professor Thomas Ohlgren has recently shown that the Gest may be have performed for the cloth guilds that were founded in the reign of Edward III. Ohlgren shows there are a lots of references which make Robin sound like a cloth merchant of Edward III's day. Even the food Robin serves his guests is taken from the guild menus where this story may have originally been read. At a 2003 conference, Ohlgren revised his opinion and felt that the king in the Gest may have been a combination of Edwards III and IV, as if asking the current king to act like his famous predecessor.

A Gentrified Outlaw

Knight feels that the Gest is not entirely reflective of the earliest Robin Hood, and Robin is already slightly "gentrified in the story". The poem does feature a Robin Hood who advocates washing one's hands and taking off one's cap before dining. A most mannerly outlaw.

But this is still not a completely civilized outlaw. As Knight also notes [in his book Robin Hood: A Complete Study of the English Outlaw, p.81], the ballad "advocates massive theft from the church, civic insurrection against and murder of a properly appointed sheriff, breach of legitimate agreement with a king, and it imagines that all those things can lead to a lengthy and happy life."

Knight also points out that while it sounds better to call the story "the Gest", the proper title is "A Gest", one of many Robin Hood tales.

An Original or Borrowing from the Past?

On the other hand, Professor J.C. Holt feels that the story of the knight and abbot is the most original element of the early Robin Hood stories.

Yet it also contains pseudo-Arthurian imagery and themes from other outlaw legends. Thomas E. Kelly notes that there are several borrowings from the earlier outlaw romance of Fouke fitz Waryn.

"Some of the incidents in Fouke fitz Waryn and A Gest of Robyn Hode are, for example, to close to be accounted for by 'common tradition' or coincidence -- the game of truth and consequences by which those who lie are robbed, while those who tell the truth keep their money; the trick of enticing the enemy into a forest trap by promising him a long-horned stag; the captured king or sheriff swearing an oath not to harm the outlaw and then breaking it; and the wounded sidekick begging the hero to kill him by cutting off his head."

-- A Book of Medieval Outlaws: Ten Tales in Modern English, edited by Thomas H. Ohlgren, p. 111.

Irony in the Gest

Robin Hood has a strong devotion to the Virgin Mary in this ballad. Several scholars have remarked on how parts of the ballad resembles the miracle tales connected with the Virgin. However, Douglas Gray notes that there are many ironies in Robin's devotion. Perhaps the poem is commenting "look, even an outlaw is more devout than figures of the established church". Also, Robin does use his devotion as an excuse to rob some monks claiming that the Virgin Mary promised him the money. You have the wonder how broad the grin on Robin's face was when he said that.

The debates on this ballad are far from over.

Modern Performances of the Gest

In 2001, I heard two renditions of the Gest. A CBC radio documentary featured a few lines of the ballad being droned out in relatively flat tones. The Middle English may have been correct, but it was hard to see why such boring words would last through the centuries. But Californian folk musician Bob Frank's lively version with an American twang was like a revelation. The language may have been modernized, but here was the warmth and most importantly the humour of the ballad brought to life. Although the language and musical styles would have been different, Bob's Gest was the kind you could imagine entertaining the angry English peasants, the folks of the manor hall or those in a craft guildhall (depending on what the medieval audience actually was, the subject of yet another debate). At its core, the Gest is meant to entertain. And when read with that in mind, it does.

In 2003, Nottingham music professor Paul Bracken played his scaled down version of fyttes 1, 2 and 4, the knight's story. This version had a more English favour, but still captured the essence of the ballad.

Where to Find the Gest:

The Gest is available in several collections of Robin Hood ballads. I've listed a few of the collections below.

The Gest with extensive notes and commentary by Professors Knight and Ohlgren is available online at The Robin Hood Project at the University of Rochester. Click here to go directly to the Gest. Click here for Stephen Knight and Thomas Ohlgren's introduction to the ballad. You can also find the same edition in book form below.

ROBIN HOOD AND OTHER OUTLAW TALES edited by Stephen Knight and Thomas Ohlgren. It's a whopping 700 pages filled with ballads, plays, and historical background. Much of this book is online at  The Robin Hood Project at the University of Rochester.
Buy it on Amazon.com
Buy it on Amazon.co.uk
Buy it on Amazon.ca

RYMES OF ROBYN HOOD; AN INTRODUCTION TO THE ENGLISH OUTLAW by R.B. Dobson and J. Taylor. Alan Sutton: Gloucester, UK, 1989. Originally published by Heinemann in 1976, this is a classic collection of ballads and poems with a wonderful historical introduction. A new edition was released in 1997 with an updated foreword.
Buy the 1997 edition on Amazon.com
Buy the 1997 edition on Amazon.co.uk
Buy the 1997 edition on Amazon.ca

ROBIN HOOD A Collection of All the Ancient Poems, Songs, and Ballads, Now Extant, Relative to that Celebrated English Outlaw by Joseph Ritson. Cambridge University Press reprinted Joseph Ritson's extremely influential 1795 collection in two paperback volumes. Ritson's introduction in the first volume shapes our modern conception of the characters. (The Gest is in volume 1.)
Buy Volume 1 on Amazon.com
Buy Volume 2 on Amazon.com

Buy Volume 1 on Amazon.co.uk
Buy Volume 2 on Amazon.co.uk

THE EARLY RYMES OF ROBYN HOOD: An Edition of the Texts, ca. 1425 - 1560 edited by Thomas H. Ohlgren and Lister M. Matheson. Tempe: Arizona Center for Medieval and Renaissance Studies, 2013. In most volumes, the Robin Hood texts are edited - variant versions are combined to "produce the best text", typos are "fixed" and spelling and punctuation is adjusted for a modern audience. All very helpful for the general reader, but those editions don't give a true picture of the original sources. This includes reproductions of the texts of Robin Hood and the Monk (including a previously unpublished fragment), Robin Hood and the Potter, seven different editions of A Gest of Robyn Hode and the three early plays. It is a very useful volume for advanced studies.
Buy it on Amazon.com
Buy it on Amazon.co.uk
Buy it on Amazon.ca

MEDIEVAL OUTLAWS: TWELVE TALES IN MODERN ENGLISH edited by Thomas H. Ohlgren. Robin wasn't the only medieval outlaw. This book includes translations of the outlaw adventures of Fulk Fitz Warin, William (Braveheart) Wallace, Adam Bell and others, including A Gest of Robyn Hode. (Updated from the earlier edition which only featured ten tales. The new cover, not pictured here, features a photo I took - the same one that forms the graphic in the top left corner of this page.)
Medieval Outlaws: Twelve Tales in Modern English Translation edited by Thomas Ohlgren on Amazon.com
Medieval Outlaws: Twelve Tales in Modern English Translation edited by Thomas Ohlgren on Amazon.co.uk
Medieval Outlaws: Twelve Tales in Modern English Translation by Thomas H. Ohlgren on Amazon.ca

A Little Gest of Robin Hood by Bob Frank.  Bob's lively translation of one of the earliest Robin Hood ballads. Although it's recorded in a thoroughly American "talking blues" style, Bob has captured the humour and spirit of the original ballad. The Robin Hood ballads were meant to entertain people -- here's someone who gets that. It's available on his website www.bobfranksongs.com

Buy Bob Frank's A Little Gest of Robin Hood on Amazon.com

Buy Bob Frank's A Little Gest of Robin Hood on Amazon.co.uk

Buy Bob Frank's A Little Gest of Robin Hood on Amazon.ca

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases from the links associated with these interviews (at no additonal cost to you).

Where to go from here:

If you enjoyed this Spotlight, check out the following:

Contact Us

© Text and Location pictures, Copyright 2019 Allen W. Wright - All Rights Reserved
Other pictures and quoted text are copyright their respective owners and used under fair use for the purpose of criticism and review.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases from the links associated with these interviews (at no additonal cost to you).

This page is a part of Robin Hood -- Bold Outlaw of Barnsdale and Sherwood